Nobody ever bragged about their phone’s SIM tray, which is why it vanished with so little protest. Apple dropped it from US iPhone 14 models in 2022, and the iPhone Air later went eSIM-only as a design choice. Most Android makers still ship dual-slot trays. I think they’re right to, and the gap deserves more attention than it gets.

What a paperclip used to do

A dead phone used to be a thirty-second problem. Eject the tray, drop the card into any other handset, and your number was back. The SIM was a physical object that belonged to you, and that was the whole system.

With eSIM, your number is a profile provisioned by your carrier and bound to a specific device. If that device is cracked, drowned, or stolen, getting the profile back means going through the carrier: an app, a QR code, a support chat, sometimes a store visit with ID. That’s fine on a Tuesday at home. It’s miserable at a train station in another country with a dead phone and no second device to log in from.

The travel argument is real, but it’s the wrong one

Buying a data plan for Japan from your couch before the flight beats queuing at an airport kiosk, and I’d never argue otherwise. But that case only shows that eSIM should exist. It doesn’t show the tray should go. Phones with both give you the convenience and the fallback, and the cost of keeping a tray is a few millimeters of internal space.

Quick Start

Apple’s answer is that eSIMs transfer easily between iPhones. That’s true, as long as the old phone is alive and in your hand.

The cross-platform question

Moving between iPhone and Android has historically been the clumsy case, since each platform handled eSIM transfer in its own way. Both companies have talked about smoothing this out, and I’d expect it to keep improving. But the experience still depends heavily on your carrier’s willingness to cooperate, and carriers have never been known for that. Anyone who has tried to port a number out of a reluctant one knows how this goes.

The argument for removing the tray is mostly an argument about industrial design and about what manufacturers would rather do with the space. Whether carriers will ever make reissuing a profile as easy as sliding a card out of a phone, I don’t know. So far they haven’t had much reason to.